The Jobs Number Nobody Saw Coming: S&P 500 Hits Record High as the Fed Runs Out of Arguments to Raise Rates

Markets have spent months hanging on a single number: employment. This Friday, August 8th, they got it with a clarity that the real economy rarely delivers. July’s nonfarm payrolls posted a net contraction—meaning jobs were lost on an adjusted basis—while wage growth came in below consensus forecasts. The immediate result was a sweeping repricing of the monetary policy landscape: the probability of the Federal Reserve (Fed) raising rates at its September meeting collapsed, and the S&P 500 closed at a new all-time high.

What the Jobs Report Is Actually Saying

A nonfarm payrolls report showing a contraction does not automatically mean the US economy is in freefall. Monthly employment figures are volatile, subject to revisions, and sensitive to seasonal factors that can distort the headline reading. What this number does do is remove the most immediate pressure on the Fed to tighten further. When the labour market cools—even for a single month—the most hawkish members of the committee lose their empirical footing for justifying additional rate hikes. And rates markets priced that in real time.

The underlying logic runs as follows: if wages are not growing strongly, the inflationary pressure stemming from consumption moderates. Without that pressure, the Fed has less reason to restrict the economy further through higher rates. It is a chain of reasoning investors know well, which is why the reaction was both swift and broad.

Why the S&P 500 Record Deserves Some Nuance

An index touching all-time highs is a powerful signal about market sentiment. But it is worth being careful not to conflate euphoria with structural resilience. Two elements warrant separate examination:

  • The winning sectors are telling. Software and gold mining led the day’s gains. The former benefits directly from a lower-rate environment, because its valuations—anchored to future cash flows—improve when the discount rate on those flows falls. The latter acts as a barometer of monetary anxiety: gold was already trading near $4,295 per ounce, and companies such as Newmont (NEM) rose nearly 6% on the back of the metal’s strength and the prospect of lower rates.
  • BofA’s sentiment indicator is flashing a warning signal. On the very day the S&P 500 set a record, Bank of America strategists flagged that their bull-bear indicator had reached its most extreme level of optimism since 2021—the year before the worst equity bear market since the financial crisis. Bank of America is recommending that investors reduce exposure to risk assets and rotate into more defensive positions. This is not a crash call: it is a note of caution grounded in the historical tendency for markets to correct when consensus turns almost unanimously bullish.

The Geopolitical Noise the Market Has Yet to Fully Digest

As equity indices celebrated the jobs print, BlackRock raised the alarm over an unusual and potentially disruptive development: the United States had reportedly sold euros to support the Japanese yen without giving prior notice to European policymakers. For the world’s largest asset manager, this unilateral move not only heightens geopolitical risk but also makes long-dated government bonds less attractive—by casting doubt on the degree of coordination among the major monetary powers. The yen-dollar carry trade, which already generated significant turbulence in 2024, remains a latent source of volatility that cannot be ignored.

The Good-Data Trap

The principal risk on a day like today is that markets price in the perfect scenario far too quickly: a dovish Fed, inflation under control, sustained growth. That trifecta rarely holds for long without friction. If July’s reading turns out to be a statistical anomaly and August’s report shows a rebound in job creation, the narrative will reverse just as rapidly. Moreover, a labour market that is genuinely deteriorating is no good news for corporate earnings over the medium term either.

The line between a soft landing and a hard one will continue to be written one data point at a time. July’s print buys breathing room—not guarantees.

What to Watch Next

Three factors will command attention in the weeks ahead: the revisions to the July figure (published alongside the August report in early September), the minutes of the July FOMC meeting—which will offer clues as to how many members had already shifted toward a more neutral stance before today’s data—and the trajectory of gold prices, which in this environment serve as a real-time gauge of expectations for real interest rates. If the metal continues to rally, markets will be signalling their conviction that the Fed is not only done hiking: it is beginning to lay the groundwork for cuts.

🇪🇸 Versión en español: El dato de empleo que nadie esperaba: el S&P 500 bate récord mientras la Fed pierde argumentos para subir tipos

trader diary

What if the next piece reached you before it happened?

Monday to Friday, 1h35 before the New York cash open: the pre-market with levels, the calendar and the trading idea of the day. On Sunday, the weekly wrap and the week ahead. Free. No spam. One click to unsubscribe.

You will get an email to confirm (anti-bot). If it does not arrive, check your spam folder.