Nike, Lululemon, Deckers and On Holding: Who’s Losing Ground and Who Can Stage a Comeback
The athleisure sector — that category blending performance sportswear with everyday wear — was one of the pandemic’s great beneficiaries. Now it is settling the bill. Nike, Lululemon, Deckers Outdoor and On Holding have seen their share prices retreat sharply over recent quarters, and the combination of factors driving the decline is structural enough to warrant serious analysis: this is not merely a technical correction, but a fundamental reset of expectations.
Three forces hitting the sector simultaneously
The first factor is persistent inflation. Although it has moderated from its 2022–2023 peaks, the middle-income consumer continues to prioritise essential spending over $150 premium trainers. Sportswear brands, which conditioned the market to steady price increases throughout the pandemic era, are now encountering genuine resistance at the point of sale.
The second factor is tariffs. The Trump administration has maintained an aggressive trade policy that raises the cost of Asian supply chains — Vietnam, Indonesia, China — where the vast majority of athletic footwear and apparel sold in the US is manufactured. That additional cost must either be passed through to the end price (with the risk of losing volume) or absorbed into the margin (with the risk of disappointing on earnings). There is no clean way out.
The third factor is the normalisation of post-pandemic demand. The boom in home fitness, running, yoga and urban hiking generated artificially elevated demand between 2020 and 2022. That base effect has now exhausted itself. Brands that calibrated their expansion plans around that exceptional demand now find themselves sitting on excess inventory with growth expectations the market is no longer willing to underwrite.
Company by company: the same sector, different ailments
Nike is the most complex case. Its problems are not merely cyclical: the company has been losing share in the performance segment to more agile competitors for some time, and its push into direct-to-consumer (DTC) has damaged distributor relationships without yet delivering the promised profitability. Recovering creative and operational leadership simultaneously is a task the market is unwilling to pay for in advance. Its P/E ratio remains elevated for a company with stalled growth.
Lululemon faces a different challenge: it has saturated its core North American female customer base, and its international expansion — China in particular — is not offsetting the domestic slowdown. The brand remains powerful, but the growth narrative that once justified premium valuations has broken down, at least for now.
Deckers, owner of UGG and HOKA, presents a more nuanced picture. HOKA has been the sector’s standout asset in recent years, but explosive growth attracts imitators, and investors are beginning to question whether that pace is sustainable. UGG, meanwhile, remains heavily seasonal, which continues to constrain full-year earnings visibility.
On Holding is the most compelling case of the four. The Swiss brand — in which Roger Federer is a cornerstone shareholder — has built something rare: genuine product identity, expanding margins and a loyal customer base willing to pay full price. Its tariff exposure is real, but its cost structure and premium positioning give it more levers to pull than its peers. Its market capitalisation has fallen in line with the broader sector, yet its underlying business fundamentals have diverged favourably.
Why the market punishes all equally — and why that creates opportunity
When a sector enters a mode of generalised risk aversion, investors tend to sell first and analyse later. That means companies with very different dynamics — Nike burdened by deep-seated strategic issues, On Holding still accelerating — were trading at similar discounts just weeks ago. The market is an efficient pricing mechanism over the long run, but in the short term it can be an efficient panic mechanism.
- Nike: The restructuring is real but slow. It is not the worst business in the group, but it is the one that requires the most time to justify a re-rating.
- Lululemon: A solid brand with reduced near-term visibility. A recovery is possible, but the catalyst is not yet apparent.
- Deckers: HOKA is the asset to watch. If sales momentum holds, the share price correction will prove to have been excessive.
- On Holding: Of the four, it best combines organic growth, margin expansion and product differentiation. The recent selloff looks more like sector contagion than any deterioration in fundamentals.
What to watch from here
The coming months will determine whether the sector is finding a floor or has further to fall. The key data points to monitor: the trajectory of discretionary consumer spending in the US — particularly retail sales figures for July and August — any shift in tariff policy that might ease supply chain pressure, and On Holding’s quarterly results, which will be the first real test of whether its growth story can withstand the current macro environment. In a sector where everything has sold off indiscriminately, differentiation is once again what matters.
🇪🇸 Versión en español: Nike, Lululemon, Deckers y On Holding: quién pierde el paso y quién puede recuperarlo
What if the next piece reached you before it happened?
Monday to Friday, 1h35 before the New York cash open: the pre-market with levels, the calendar and the trading idea of the day. On Sunday, the weekly wrap and the week ahead. Free. No spam. One click to unsubscribe.


Leave A Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.